Preseason is not even over and we've already had multiple suspensions and at least two incidents (one substantiated, one alleged) of bigotry. Come on, world. Grow up a little. Hockey is better than this.
I was genuinely shaken to read about the
banana-throwing incident that happened last week during the Flyers/Red Wings game. I liked Simmonds when he played for the Kings. He always seemed like a classy dude, and he had a level-headed response to what was clearly a racist gesture from a so-called fan of the game. And if there is one thing that I fucking hate in this world, it is racism.
...0r, more accurately, bigotry of any type.
So I was particularly saddened to hear that Simmonds, himself a victim of public hatred, allegedly
called Sean Avery a "fucking f-ggot" during the most recent Flyers/Rangers game.
I don't know what Simmonds said. I don't even know if Avery was truthful about what he heard. With this level of ambiguity, Simmonds could have done one of three things:
(1) denied saying it, and explained that the f-word is reprehensible, and that he would never say it,
(2) admitted it and explained why it was completely terrible of him to say it and why he will never say it again, and apologize to Avery and everyone who heard it or heard about it, or
(3) say he couldn't remember.
He took Option 3 and basically said that he can't remember saying that because things were so heated.
According to my friend who plays hockey, the f-word is still sadly widely accepted as an insult in the world of male sports. So to me, Simmonds' "denial" speaks volumes. He can't remember if he said the f-word? Because it is so common and is just thrown around so frequently that saying it is not a big deal? That is unacceptable.
Let me be super clear: there is no place in this world where yelling the f-word at someone as an insult is appropriate, just as there is no place in this world where throwing a banana at a black guy is appropriate. Both are examples of hate speech. The fact that Simmonds was on the ice and in the heat of the game when he supposedly (allegedly) said this makes absolutely no difference to me. So is the rule now that you can say these things if you are really really upset? Uh...does that mean that I can call someone a n-gger in the middle of my beer league dodgeball game if I am really pissed off that day? Of course not.
I have seen people argue that it is just a word, and that actions are more important than words. Even if that is true, that doesn't mean that words are unimportant. Words still matter. Ideas matter. The idea that being gay is somehow worse than being straight matters. Comparing words and actions is asinine. Words are words and actions are actions. Both can be punishable without arguing that they are equivalent or identical.
I've also seen people argue that Avery had it coming because he makes a living at getting under someone's skin, and/or because he supports gay rights, and/or because he himself might be gay (I take issue with that last one...you can be straight and still support gay rights.) I don't give a shit about that. I don't care if Simmonds said this to a guy who was going down on another dude at that exact moment. No one "deserves" hate speech. Not even Sean Avery.
There is no on-ice exception for hate speech. The rink is not a consequence-free zone. I'm not saying that players can't chirp at each other or even ask if the ref is fucking blind or tell someone that their girlfriend was a hot piece of ass that morning. But they cannot engage in hate speech that targets someone's race or sexual orientation. This is bigotry. And if an NHL player can't tell the difference between chirping and bigotry, just let me know, and I'll give them a list of 100 non-bigoted insults that they can feel free to use freely against referees and the other team.
Let me also be clear about one more thing: What happened to Simmonds in Ontario is still completely reprehensible. And conversely, Simmonds doesn't get a free pass to "pay forward" the bigotry that he experienced by yelling the f-word at Sean Avery.
I hope this is the last post that I write about hateful behavior this season. Hockey as a sport is better than this.